The Absence in the Presence during Liturgical Distancing 2020



Title: The Incredulity of Saint Thomas [Click for larger image view]
Caravaggio's "The Incredulity of Saint Thomas"
In John 20, the story of Thomas, we do not have an explicit statement that he put his finger in the nail holes or in the lacerated side of Christ. Was the invitation enough? 

The invitation is to enter the mystery: “Put your finger here…only believe.” (20:27) The “hole” in Christ’s side is the mystery. The risen Christ calls Thomas and all of us to enter the mystery. In that we and Thomas are not different in time and space.

In Compassionate Christ, Compassionate People*, Bob Hurd muses on the silence of the congregation after reception and before the post-communion prayer. “It signifies the beyond words character of union, corresponding to comtemplatio in the fourth stage of lection divina.” (p.230) Hurd goes on to call this “companionable silence” entry into the Mystery. The silence after reception of the Eucharist is (if it is observed in practice**) the moment of stillness in the experience of the Mystery of the risen Christ. It is going beyond any notions of possession or physicality. Thomas encountered the Mystery. It is the anticipation, as Hurd notes, of the ascension. “Believing without seeing corresponds to recognizing the absence in the presence.” (p. 232) Christ is present as the soul animates the body, though it is not the body.

Could the extended hiatus from Eucharist during the Covid-19 pandemic be our extended post-communion silence when we encounter the absence in the presence of the risen Christ? Might we observe it as a time to be silent before the mystery of what we otherwise take for granted? Can this be a silence to encounter Christ truly risen, present in the absence, present behind locked doors? Christ is accessible in the mystery. Paul wrote, “Listen, I will tell you a mystery! We will not all die, but we will all be changed…” (1 Cor. 15:51) The silence is an encounter with our own mystery—that in Christ we are all being transformed, the mortal body putting on Christ’s immortality.

For catholic and apostolic Christians, the post-communion silence is a strange gift—a season to behold the mystery of Christ risen, present in the absence. And here, like Thomas Aquinas***, we fall silent because like Thomas the apostle, lost in the mystery , it dawns upon us as total awe and transforming awareness, “My Lord and my God.!”

Daniel

*Bob Hurd, Compassionate Christ, Compassionate People: Liturgical Foundations of Christian Spirituality. (Collegeville: Liturgical Press Academic, 2019).

**In searching various liturgical traditions including Roman Catholic, Episcopal, Evangelical Lutheran, and United Methodist, I could find no rubric for observing such a silence. In subsequent a subesequent email exchange with Bob Hurd, he directed me to the General Instructions on the Roman Missal nos. 56 and 88 which deal with silence in the liturgy of the Word and the liturgy of the Eucharist. 

***The great theologian fell silent from writing reputed to have said, “I can write no more. All that I have written seems like straw.” Accessed on 4/19/2020 at https://christianhistoryinstitute.org/incontext/article/aquinas

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Image
“Kyrie Eleison”—A Prayer for When We Don’t Know How to Pray? President Bush just completed his speech from the library of the White House, outlining his current plan for a final go at victory/salvage in Iraq. By now the blogosphere is churning with positions on the Presidents proposal. Viva democracy in these United States. But what are we Christians to do? Shall we join in partisan debate, give thumbs up or down, and further enflame the polarization of America? Undoubtedly, many of us will do so, right, left and middle. However, on deeper reflection, I wonder if as Christian communities of prayer, we should at least pray; indeed, is not prayer the distinctive thing we are called to do. But how do Christians pray in such times without rehearsing our own political views, telling God (and coincidentally, others with whom we pray) where we are as another hellish moment comes upon the world? Lord have mercy on us when we engage in extemporaneous prayer in such times: we will likely use wa
Read more
On Doing Our Liturgical “Thing” Many of us have been tempted to alter or paraphrase a prayer, litany, or liturgical text to “be more accessible” to the congregation. Perhaps we thought the ritual text was opaque to contemporary seekers. And, many of us have suffered (or been delighted by) such at the hands of others. What are we not aware of in these undertakings? John Donne’s poem, “Upon the Translation of the Psalmes,” (a response to the translation of the Psalter by Philip Sydney and his sister, the Countesse of Pembroke) begins: Eternall God, (for whom who ever dare Seek new expression doe the Circle square, And thrust into strait corners of poore wit Thee who art cornerlesse and infinite) Donne, in this little knot of convolution, as I call it, seems to be wrestling with the limits of creativity and human innovation. Might this at least be a caution to us “who dare” to make “new expressions” in the church’s prayer? Is everything our hearts, minds, and words conspire to articulate
Read more
Confession of an Ancient-Future Worshiper “How shall we sing the Lord’s song in a foreign land,” asks the Psalmist. It was a question the exiles asked. It is my question too as I visit churches in my journeying around the United States. No, I am not a Mystery Worshiper for the Ship of Fools ( http://ship-of-fools.com/Mystery/index.html .) You may think that is odd for a Christian to feel like worship in any church is a foreign land. So, I will be specific and charitable, as I mean no harm. Consider this a confessional rather than negatively critical. Last Sunday I worshiped in a nearly 15,000 member megachurch at the invitation of a friend. The high-tech music, lights and sound was professional and effective. The preaching was strong, compassionate and visionary. On the scale of excellence I would give this congregation high marks for what they do according to their aims and purposes. Here, however, is the confession: I was not at home here. It was more than the theology that I couldn’
Read more